connecting good folks, with good pies, everyday.

Our Pies

The G.O.A.T
$40.00
Add To Cart
Brand New Day-O
$40.00
Add To Cart
Gift Card
from $25.00
Purchase
Ok, Boomer
$40.00
Add To Cart
Cookies & Dreams
$40.00
Add To Cart
Blurred Limes. Key Lime pie
$40.00
Add To Cart
Seize the Day, Bacon & Cheddar Quiche
$40.00
Add To Cart
Peanut Butter And Jealous
$42.00
Add To Cart
The Three Sisters. Mixed Berry pie
$40.00
Add To Cart
Beach, don't kill my vibe. Coconut Cream Pie
$40.00
Add To Cart
Come "pie" with me Pie Flight
$25.00
Add to Cart

  • Share your story with someone.

  • Call your mom or dad just to say I love you.

  • Reconnect with an old friend you’ve lost touch with over the years. Share a memory you carry with you.

  • Smile at someone who looks sad.

Surprise Your Friend with a Delicious Pie!

At Mixed Fillings Pie Shop, we believe there's no better way to show appreciation for a friend than by treating them to one of our mouthwatering pies. With an assortment of delectable flavors, we are confident that we have the perfect pie to make your friend's day extra special.